“Creatine is just water weight, and it hurts your kidneys”
Creatine holds a little water at first, but with lifting it adds real lean mass, and trials show no kidney harm in healthy people.
Claim check
A major meta-analysis found muscle gains stopped climbing at about 1.6 g per kilogram a day, which works out to roughly 0.7 g per pound.
“You need 1 gram of protein per pound of body weight to build muscle.”
More protein helps lifters, but gains level off near 1.6 g/kg, about 0.7 g per pound, making 1 g per pound a generous ceiling.
1.62g/kg/day
Daily intake where extra protein stopped adding lean mass
Source 10.73g per lb/day
The same plateau converted to pounds (1.62 divided by 2.2046)
Source 10.3kg
Extra fat-free mass from protein supplements during lifting programs
Source 11.4–2.0g/kg/day
Daily range the ISSN says is sufficient for most exercisers
Source 2Our own summary of the sources listed at the bottom of this page.
Every chart is drawn from the published estimates. Bars and intervals show the uncertainty; a dashed line marks no difference.
The 2018 meta-analysis placed the point where extra protein stopped adding lean mass at 1.62 g/kg a day, shown with its 95% confidence interval. The 1 g per pound rule (about 2.2 g/kg) sits at the upper edge of that interval.
In a dose-response meta-analysis of 105 papers and 5,402 participants, each small increase in protein added about three times more lean mass at lower intakes than at higher ones. Numbers are from Tagawa and colleagues, Nutrition Reviews.
Source: 3Nutrition Reviews, 2020
The claim
The evidence
A side-by-side summary of the social media rule and what pooled trials found. Sources: Morton 2018 and the ISSN 2017 position stand.
Written and drawn by go4 with AI assistance (Claude, by Anthropic) after reading these sources, and checked against them. No text or figures were copied. Checked Oct 2026.
Creatine holds a little water at first, but with lifting it adds real lean mass, and trials show no kidney harm in healthy people.
Hard sets that end close to failure help growth, but actually reaching failure is not required for most people.